 | Railroad Commission of Kentucky - Municipal services - 1910 - 576 pages
...been charged and collected are reasonable — that is a judicial act; but an entirely different thing to prescribe rates which shall be charged in the future — that is a legislative act." It is to be noticed that the question with which the learned Justice was then confronted was whether... | |
 | Law reports, digests, etc - 1906 - 1166 pages
...been charged and collected are reasonable — that is a judicial act; but an entirely different thing to prescribe rates which shall be charged in the future — that is a legislative act" The court did not seek to fix a rate for future service by appellant, but exercised jurisdiction to... | |
 | Electronic journals - 1914 - 812 pages
...been charged and collected are reasonable, — that is a judicial act; but an entirely different thing to prescribe rates which shall be charged in the future, — that is a legislative act." In Louisville, NO & TR Co. v. Mississippi " the line between interstate and intrastate commerce was thus... | |
 | United States - 1897 - 836 pages
...charged and collected are reasonable,— that is a judicial act ; but it is an entirely different thing to prescribe rates which shall be charged in the future, — that is a legislative act" The difference between correcting evils and ratemaking is the difference between punishing law-breakers... | |
 | 1897 - 550 pages
...been charged and collected are reasonable- — that is a judicial act; but an entirely different thing to prescribe rates which shall be charged in the future — that is a legislative act. (Railway Co. v. Minnesota, 134 US 418, 458; Reagan v. Farmers' Loan & Trust Co., 154 US 362, 397; Railway... | |
 | Joseph Nimmo (Jr.) - 1899 - 404 pages
...been charged and collected are reasonable — that is a judicial act ; but an entirely different thing to prescribe rates which shall be charged in the future — that is a legislative act." Now do you not see that you are attempting to prove that a judicial act when associated with a legislative... | |
| |
It is one thing to inquire whether the rates which have been charged and collected are reasonable — that is a judicial act ; but an entirely different thing to prescribe rates which shall be charged in the future — that is a legislative act. 
