Irving pace; Cushing, Marshall, secretary National Association of Manufacturers; Cutting, R. Fulton, 32 Nassau street; Davenport, Ira, 31 East Thirty-ninth street; De Forest, Robert W., 30 Broad street; Devine, Edward T., 105 East Twenty second street; Dix, Rev. Morgan, 27 West Twenty-fifth street; Dresser, D. Le Roy, president merchants' association; *Drumon, Rev. Thomas, 22 State street; *Edgar, George P., box 1544; *Ely, Arthur H., 56 Wall street; Ely, Robert Ershine, 23 West Forty-fourth street; *Evans, Anthony H., Rev., 296 Madison avenue; Fairchild, Miss Sally, 39 East Thirty-first street; Folks, Homer, secretary State charities aid association: *Girdner, Dr. J. H.; Giddings, Prof. Franklin H., 150 West Seventy-ninth street; Grant, Madison, 11 Wall street; *Gunton, Prof. Geo., Union Square; Hansman, Carl A., 96 Broadway; Harmon, Wm. E., 256 Broadway; Hill, Wm. B., 56 Pine street; Holt, Henry, 29 West Twenty-third street; Hopkins, Sheldon, 31 Nassau street; Hibbard, Thomas H., 16 West Fifty eighth street; Hunter, Robert, 184 Eldridge street; Huntington, Francis C., 49 Wall street; Huntington, Rev. W. R., 804 Broadway; *Jenkins, E. Fellows, 297 Fourth avenue; Kasmire, B. F., 230 West Twenty-fourth street; King, James G., 80 Broadway; Light, Harry L., care Cluett Coon Co., Union Square; Livingston, Edward, 17 East Seventy-fourth street; Marshall, Henry Rutgers, 3 West Twenty-ninth street; *MacMurray, Rev. David A., 53 Washington Square; Mead, S. C., assistant secretary merchants' association; merchants' association, D. Le Roy Dresser, president; Moody, John, 27 Pine street; Murray, James B., 69 Wall street; National Association of Manufacturers, David M. Parry, president; Neave, Charles, 80 Broadway; Norton, Eliot, 135 Broadway; * O'Burne, Gen. Jas. R., 66 Third avenue; Appenheimer, Dr. Hey. S., 6 East Thirty-second street; Parkhurst, Rev. C. H., 133 East Thirtyfifth street; Potter, Right Rev. Henry C., 29 Lafayette place; Pryor, Hon. Roger A., supreme court; Rainsford, Rev. W. I., 209 East Sixteenth. street; Reynolds, James B., care of Century Club, 7 West Forty third street; Rice, Edwin T., jr., 59 Wall street; * Ringwalt, Ralph C., 57 Rivington street; Rodd, Hon. J. Hampden, 23 Park avenue; Rood, Henry E., care of Mail and Express, 203 Broadway; Smith, Rev. Walter E. Clifton, 7 West Tenth street, associate rector, Church of the Ascension; Spahr, Charles B., 287 Fourth avenue; Springer, M. A., 81 Fulton street; Terry, Seth Sprague, 86 Broadway; Tucker, Allen, 15 Thirty-eighth street; Tucker, Frank, 105 East Twenty-second street; Webster, Rev. George S., 306 East Forty-second street; Wentz, Mrs. James G., 312 West Eighty-second street; White, F. (Winthrop), 81 Fulton street; White, Henry, 116 Bible House; Wilson, James Grant, 15 East Seventy-fourth street; * Wylie, Rev. David G., Scotch Presbyterian Church: Woman's Republican Club. Nyack-Maynard, Mrs. E. H.

Ovid-Porter, Henry Axtell.

Persia-Babcock, Geo. C., Cattaraugus County.

Rochester-Clothing Cutters' Local Union 136, United Garment Workers of America; society for the organization of charity.

Rosebank, Fort Wadsworth-Harmon, M. F.

Saugerties-Peters, Wm. H. (Rev.).

Schenectady-Swits, J. L.

Shokan, Ulster County-Davis, De Witt C.

Syracuse-Burlingame, Mrs. W. A., Sedgwick farm.

Utica-Illingsworth, J. J.

Wellsville-Jones, Gertrude F. (Mrs. P.), 191 Main street.

West New Brighton-Curtis, Anna Shaw (Mrs.).

West Winfield-Wood, Statia Brill (Mrs. F. E.).

NORTH CAROLINA.

Asheville-Roebling, John A.

Wittenberg * Smith, Z. X.

OHIO.

American Federation of Labor, Ohio State Branch

*Labor commissioner of State of Ohio.

*Ohio State Grange, Patrons of Husbandry.

Trades and Labor Assembly of Ohio.

Ruhrivein, Hon. William, labor commissioner State of Ohio.
Ada-Tehr, H. S., president Ohio Normal University.
Akron-Norris, Wm. A., 166 South Main street.

Crestown-Ellis, E. C.

Cincinnati-General secretary associated charities, Hubbard, C. M.; Hubbard, C. M., general secretary associated charities; Rianhard, J. V. L. jr., 61 Blymer Building; Turner, F. T., 21 Mitchell Building.

Cleveland-Cleveland Chamber of Commerce; Bemis, Edward W., superintendent waterworks; *Johnson, Loren A., Masonic Temple; Keeler, Harvey, Savings Building; Saal, Dr. Geo. F., 39 Ontario street. Columbus-Trades Assembly.

Dayton-Associated charities, 231 Jefferson street; Brown, O. B.; Platt, J. D., treasurer Barney & Smith Car Co.

Delta-President of trustees of Ohio State penitentiary; Brigham, J. H., president of trustees of Ohio State penitentiary. Findley-Galloway, C. L., 614 Second street. Hamilton-Cooperative Trades and Labor Council. Kimbolton-Alloway, C. E.

Massilon-Trades and Labor Assembly.

Millersburg-* Eichenberger, J.

Perrysburg-Goodman, Oliver, Wood County.

Rex-Freeman, C. M.

Salem-Tatem, A. K.

Sandusky-Mack, I. F., proprietor of The Register.

Springfield-Associated charities; Holman, R. L., on executive committee Ohio State Grange Patrons of Husbandry; Miller, Harvey L., Bushnell Building.

Toledo-Wading, William J., president National Wholesale Druggists' Association.

West Carrolton-Friend, J. H. (Paper Company).

Zanesville * Suter, J. Hope, Zanesville and Ohio River Railway Company.

OREGON.

Portland Secretary associated charities, Walpole, W. R.; Bates, Geo. W., 161 Russell street; Blackburn, Rev. Alexander, 427 Market street; Chance, Dr. Geo. H., 808 The Dekum; Walpole, W. R., secretary associated charities; *Minchester, J. S., 44 Sherlock Building.

PENNSYLVANIA.

Knights of Labor Social Assembly, No. 1562.
Allentown-Steinhaeuser, W. P., 201 North Ninth street.
Ashbourne-Kenks, Horace.

Beaver Falls-Filler, Hugh R.

Columbia-Kauffman, Andrew J.

Dany Station-Enders, Leslie G., secretary Chestnut Ridge Lodge, No. 310, Brotherhood of Locomotive Firemen.

Eddystone-*Whittaker, William, 251 Lexington avenue.

Hazelton-Hill, C. F.

Homesdale-Loris, Nicholas.

Kane-Kane Labor League.

McKeesport-Goodwin, Samuel J.; * Shale, J. B., president News Publishers' Press Association.

Philadelphia-Allen, Wm. N., 557 Church lane, Germantown; Glass Bottle Blowers; Allen N. Penrose, 710 The Bourse; Badger, W. H., care of Philadelphia Inquirer; Edmunds, Hon. Geo. F., 1507 Spruce street, Burlington, Vt.; Fisher, Sydney G., 328 Chestnut street; Gassner, Rev. Geo. A., 105 Queen street; Grocers and Importers' Exchange, John E. Poore, secretary; Harkness, William, secretary Master Builders' Exchange; Jenks, Robert D., 920 Clinton street; Kline, Mr. M. N., 431 Arch street; Master Builders' Exchange, Wm. Harkness, secretary; McGuire, Peter J., box 884; National Wholesale Druggists' Association, Wm. J. Walding, president; *Payne, Theo. E., 2519 Master street; Pepper, Geo. Wharton, 701-706 Drexel Building; Poore, John E., secretary Grocers and Importers' Exchange; Wister, Owen, 328 Chestnut street.

Plymouth Christopher Wren.

Pittsburg--* American Association of Flint and Lime Glass Manufacturers; George F. Easton, actuary; association for the improvement of the poor, 440 Sixth avenue; * Easton, George F., actuary American Association of Flint and Lime Glass Managers; * examiner of department of charities; * Hamilton, R. E., acting actuary American Association of Flint and Lime Glass Manufacturers; * Local Assembly 4907; * Pittsburg Christian Patriotic Association; Collins, Stephen, Anchor Bank building; Copeland, Wm. R., 914 Jay street; *Edwards, Charles E., 706 Pennsylvania avenue; *Fitzwilliam, Rev. C. H., Fifth Avenue Baptist Church; * Hoffman, George, examiner of department of charities; Jenkinson, A. M. (R. & W. Jenkinson Company); Patton, J. E., jr., care of Pittsburgh Plate Glass Company, Carnegie Building.

Pottsville-Enterline, S. M., Mountain City Building; Wottjen, Charles H., 117 Mahantonge street.

Roxboro-Dewees, Jas. L., jr., 275 Lyceum avenue.

Scranton-Associated charities, Ezra H. Ripple, president; Cigar Makers' Union No. 295; Israel, Rogers, secretary associated charities; Powderly, Hon. T. S.

RHODE ISLAND.

East Providence-East Providence Business Mens' Association; Houston, George H., secretary business meus' association. Providence-Devoll, Frederic U., 5 Arcade Building.

SOUTH DAKOTA.

Secretary South Dakota Immigration Association, S. W. Narregang, esq.

Executive board Sioux Falls, S. Dak., Immigration Association.
Aberdeen-Narregang, S. W.

Ipswich-*Beebe, Marcus P., first vice-president National Homeseekers Association.

Pierre-De Land, Chas. E.; Thurson, Hon. Thomas, secretary of

state.

Vermilion-Droppers, Garrett, president, University of South

Dakota; Foster, Herbert B., professor of Greek, University of South Dakota; *Haley, L. E., professor of physics and chemistry, University of South Dakota; Lommon, C. P., professor of biology, University of South Dakota; Sloan, C. A., secretary University of South Dakota; Smith, Geo. M., professor of modern languages, University of South Dakota; Young, C. M., professor of history and social sciences.

TEXAS.

Austin-* National Prison Reform Association.
Beaumont-Pistote, J. D.

Galveston-* Allen, Noah; chamber of commerce, J. H. Johnson, secretary; Johnson, J. H., secretary chamber of commerce; Levy, W. T., United States immigration office; *Smith, R. Waverley, president chamber of commerce.

VERMONT.

Brattleboro-Paton, Robert L. Stuart, 36 Green street.

Burlington-Howard Relief Society, Harriet B. Willard, secretary. South Newbury-Doe, Charles C.

VIRGINIA.

Charlottesville-Boningen, P. B., faculty University of Virginia; Dabney, R. H., faculty University of Virginia; Dunnington, F. P., faculty University of Virginia; Echols, W. H., faculty University of Virginia; Fontaine, Wm. M., faculty University of Virginia; Kent, Charles W., faculty University of Virginia; Minor, Raleigh C., faculty University of Virginia; Smith, Francis H., faculty University of Virginia.

Lynchburg-Purvis, Sam. C.

Norfolk-Jones, R. Henry, care of Jesse Jones & Son, 210 Bute

street.

Richmond—* Cabell, H. L., president chamber of commerce; * chamber of commerce, H. L. Cabell, president; * Dunlop, R. A., secretary chamber of commerce; Moore, Thos. L.

Legislature.

WASHINGTON.

Washington State Immigration Society.

Everett-Bronnell, F. H., president chamber of commerce; chamber of commerce, F. H. Bronnell, president; Thornton, Walter, secretary chamber of commerce.

Puyallup-Miller, Rev. M. W.

Seattle Seattle Chamber of Commerce; Gasch, Fred, chairman King County commissioners; * Lyon, Job P., Pioneer Building; Rex, J. M., Hinckley Block; Schuyler, F. D., Treasury Department agent. Laconia-* Hempson, Walter J., 936 Pacific avenue.

WEST VIRGINIA.

Huntington—Wingets, J. W., care of Chesapeake and Ohio Railway. Wheeling Strong, F. M.

WISCONSIN.

Commonwealth-Dickinson, E. S.

Eau Claire-Secretary associated charities; * Wiltrout, Mrs. Ivah B., secretary associated charities.

Mazomamie-Kraege, F. G.

Milwaukee-Associated charities, 416 Milwaukee street; Batchelder, John, 544 Cass street; Camp, A. K., Prospect avenue; Camp, H. H., Tenth street; Flint, Wyman K., 272 Martin street; Houghton, Gep. G., 280 Prospect avenue; Kennedy, Philip D., 1126 Cedar street; Koeppen, George, editor Germania; Marks, Dr. Solon, Prospect avenue; Merchants and Manufacturers' Association, University building; Mowry, Duane; Nicholson, Right Rev. I. L., Martin street; Smith, Dr. Bryant, Prospect avenue; Spindler, William C., court-house; Tapping, E. J., Pabst Building; Wadhams, E. A., president Merchants and Manufacturers' Association, University building; Weissert, A. G., 107 Wisconsin street; Whitney, L. C., secretary Merchants and Manufacturers' Association.

The committee, at 12 o'clock meridian, adjourned until to-morrow, Friday, December 12, 1902, at 10.30 a. m.

FRIDAY, December 12, 1902.

The committee met at 10.30 a. m. Present: Senators Penrose (chairman), Fairbanks, Mason, Dryden, Clay, and McLaurin, of Mississippi.

Also, Hon. William B. Shattuc, Representative from the State of Ohio; Hon. Frank P. Sargent, Commissioner-General of Immigration; Richard K. Campbell, of the Bureau of Immigration, Treasury Depart ment; Robert Watchorn, special immigrant inspector, Montreal, Canada; John J. S. Rogers, commissioner of immigration at the port of Philadelphia; David Healy, commissioner of immigration at Vancouver, British Columbia; Hugh R. Fuller, of Beaver Falls, Pa., representing the Locomotive Engineers, etc.; James A. Sullivan, of Massachusetts, representing the Friendly Society of Engravers of America; Hon. J. M. Farquhar, of Buffalo, N. Y., ex-member of the House of Representatives and of the Industrial Commission; A. S. Anderson, passenger agent International Navigation Company; S. C. Neale, representing the International Navigation Company; Frank Morrison, secretary of the American Federation of Labor; Charles E. Edgerton, assistant secretary Immigration Restriction League, and others.

STATEMENT OF HUGH R. FULLER.

Mr. FULLER. Mr. Chairman, I represent a large majority of the organized railroad employees of the country, and I ask leave to occupy only about five or ten minutes of your time.

The CHAIRMAN. Proceed, Mr. Fuller.

Mr. FULLER. I appeared before the committee during the last session and have no desire to use up any more of its time than is really necessary. I merely wish to reply to some of the statements which have been made by those who oppose section 3, the educational test qualification, which, in my mind, is the most vital part of the bill.

I wish first to speak in regard to the statement made by the gentleman who represented the sugar growers of the Hawaiian Islands (Mr. Haywood). As I understand him he asks that this bill be so amended