THE

NORTHEASTERN REPORTER,

VOLUME 30,

CONTAINING ALL THE CURRENT DECISIONS OF THE

SUPREME COURTS OF MASSACHUSETTS, OHIO, ILLINOIS, INDIANA,
APPELLATE COURT OF INDIANA, AND THE COURT

OF APPEALS OF NEW YORK.

PERMANENT EDITION,

MARCH 18-JUNE 3, 1892.

WITH TABLE OF NORTHEASTERN CASES IN WHICH REHEARINGS HAVE BEEN DENIED.

COPYRIGHT, 1892,

BY

WEST PUBLISHING COMPANY.

JUDGES

OF THE

COURTS REPORTED DURING THE PERIOD COVERED BY THIS VOLUME.

MASSACHUSETTS–Supreme Judicial Court.
WALBRIDGE A. FIELD, CHIEF JUSTICE.

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.
CHARLES ALLEN.

JAMES M. MORTON.
OLIVER WENDELL HOLMES, JR. JOHN LATHROP.
MARCUS P. KNOWLTON.

JAMES M. BARKER.

NEW YORK-Court of Appeals.
ROBERT EARL, CHIEF JUDGE.

ASSOCIATE JUDGES.
CHARLES ANDREWS.

JOHN C. GRAY.
FRANCIS M. FINCH.

DENIS O'BRIEN.
RUFUS W. PECKHAM.

ISAAC H. MAYNARD.

Second Division.
DAVID L. FOLLETT, CHIEF JUDGE.

ASSOCIATE JUDGES.
GEORGE B. BRADLEY.

ALTON B. PARKER
ALBERT HAIGHT.

IRVING G. VANN.
CHARLES F. BROWN.

JUDSON 8. LANDON.

OHIO-Supreme Court.
MARSHALL J. WILLIAMS, CHIEF JUSTICE.

JUDGES
WILLIAM T. SPEAR.

JOSEPH P. BRADBURY.
FRANKLIN J. DICKMAN.

THADDEUS A. MINSHALL

INDIANA-Supreme Court.
BYRON K. ELLIOTT, CHIEF JUSTICE, Nov. Term, 1891.

ASSOCIATE JUDGES.
ROBERT W. McBRIDE.

WALTER OLDS.
JOHN D. MILLER.

SILAS D. COFFEY.

Appellate Court.
MILTON S. ROBINSON, CHIEF JUDGE, Nov. Term, 1891.

ASSOCIATE JUDGES.
GEORGE L. REINHARD

JAMES B. BLACK.
EDGAR D. CRUMPACKER.

JEPTHA D. NEW.

ILLINOIS-Supreme Court.
BENJAMIN D. MAGRUDER, CHIEF JUSTICE.

JUSTICES
JOHN SCHOLFIELD.

ALFRED M. CRAIG.
SIMEON P. SHOPE.

JOSEPH M. BAILEY.
DAVID J. BAKER.

JACOB W. WILKIN
(iii)*

598140