| United States. Department of Justice - Attorneys general's opinions - 1909 - 732 pages
...about it. Lord McLaren observed that it was impossible to limit the scope of the statute. He considered that ' if a workman in the reasonable performance...appellant was lifting hutches which were too heavy for him. If,' he added, ' such an occurrence as this can not be described in ordinary language as an accident,... | |
| Law reports, digests, etc - 1915 - 1230 pages
...that when "a workman In the reasonable performance of his duties sustains a psychological Injury as a result of the work he is engaged in, this is accidental Injury In the sense of the statute. If such on occurrence as this cannot be described In ordinary language да an acddent, I do not know... | |
| New Zealand. Court of Arbitration - 1908 - 118 pages
...held to be an accident within the meaning of the Act. Lord McLaren in the course of his judgment said that " if a workman in the reasonable performance...result of the work he is engaged in, .... this is an accidental injury in the sense of the statute." This passage was quoted with approval by Lord Macnaghten... | |
| Victor Rees Aronson - Employers' liability - 1909 - 580 pages
...Lord Maclaren in that case said : " I think it is impossible so to limit the scope of the statute, and if a workman, in the reasonable performance of his...injury as the result of the work he is engaged in, I consider that this is accidental injury in the sense of the statute." In accordance with this principle... | |
| Alfred Henry Ruegg - Employers' liability - 1910 - 1166 pages
...of the Act. Lord MCLAREN said, " If a workman in the reasonable performance of his duties sustains physiological injury as the result of the work he...injury in the sense of the statute." Lord KINNEAR said the injury " arose from some causes which are not definitely ascertained, except that the appellant... | |
| Climenson Yelverton Charles Dawbarn - Employers' liability - 1911 - 798 pages
...Fletcher Moulton, LJ, relied on the dictum of Lord M'Laren in 8fewart v. Wilson, •, F. 120, viz.: " If a workman in the reasonable performance of his...is accidental injury in the sense of the statute." This is exactly what it is not. The dictum, apart from its setting of the particular facts to which... | |
| United States. Solicitor of the Dept. of Commerce and Labor - Employers' liability - 1912 - 662 pages
...cases last cited. Doubtless, as said in the case of Stewart v. Wilsons & Clyde Coal Co. (5 F., 120), " if a workman, in the reasonable performance of his...physiological injury as the result of the work he is engaged on, this is an accidental injury in the sense of the statute." But there the accident consisted in... | |
| Gilbert Stone, William Andrew George Woods - Employers' liability - 1928 - 410 pages
...quotes with approval the words of Lord McLaren in STEWART u. WILSONS & CLYDE COAL Co., saying this : "If a workman in the reasonable performance of his...sustains a physiological injury as the result of the work ne is engaged in ... this is accidental injury in the sense of the statute." Finally, Lord Shand says... | |
| Walter Addington Willis - Workers' compensation - 1913 - 476 pages
...the word " accident." Becent decisions have worked closer to the opinion expressed by Lord M'LAREN that, " if a workman in the reasonable performance...this is accidental injury in the sense of the statute " (Stewart v. Wilsons and Clyde Coal Co., Limited (1902), 5 F. 120, which case was approved and the... | |
| 1913 - 736 pages
...McLaren, one of the judgeof the Court of Session (Scotland), gave the following view of an accident: ' If a workman in the reasonable performance of his...as the result of the work he is engaged in, this is an accidental injury in the sense of the statute ' (Stewart r. Wilsons and Clyde Coal Co., 5 F., 120).... | |
| |